Affordability & Christian School Choice

Paul NealSchool Leaders, The CACE RoundtableLeave a Comment

School choice is a popular conversation with Christian parents of school age children. A common element of discussion is often related to the parent’s views on mission as it relates to their involvement with the public school and the public square in general. It is interesting to see how this view of engagement can be influenced by or related to affordability. In some cases, research shows a connection between these two factors.

Some Christian parents believe their children should attend public schools in order to have an impact on and be engaged in the community. Parents often cite the desire to be part of a public school setting because of the desire to be salt and light. Research indicates these parents are less easy to convince of the value and worth of Christian education. However, trends of increasing hostility toward faith in public schools and fewer Christian counterparts today is increasingly secular limit opportunity.

The Christian school setting, however, may well be the new opportune public square – where Christians can live their lives and talk about their faith in ways that impact their community. It’s where living as a Christian in front of others, coupled with the opportunity to share your faith that the potential for most impact exists. Indeed, isn’t that the premise behind the Apostle Paul’s admonition to pray for those in authority? Freedom is necessary in order to talk about our hope.

While it is hard to change Christian parents who have chosen not to enroll in a Christian school, there is some evidence that their views are connected to cost and perceived financial value. Research I’ve been conducting with my colleague David Urban, over the past several years, in over 30 different communities, includes findings related to opinions of Christian school options when cost is not a factor. When cost is removed, the argument that it is good to be engaged in public schools for some sort of evangelical purpose tends to be less pronounced. Also, parents who previously chose public schools for Mission become much more favorable to the idea of attending a Christian school.

There is also an obvious difference in thinking between those who choose to keep their children in public school during elementary years for financial reasons and those who choose to put their children into public schools in middle or high school. Those with children in public elementary are much more likely to cite cost as the reason than those who make a move in middle or high school. However, if the group who makes the move in middle or high school has the cost factor removed, they are just as likely to think favorably toward Christian school options as the parents of elementary public school children who cited cost as a major factor.

To what extent does the hierarchical nature of the educational system add to the challenge of students being salt and light among their peers? Where can this happen most effectively? How’s the situation changed over time? Finally, if cost is a key driver in the decision making process, how can Christian schools strategize around a group who was once thought of as not likely prospects—since they may be quite movable in their school choice.


  • Paul Neal

    Paul T. Neal serves as the Director of Operations at CACE. Paul brings years of experience in marketing research and enrollment management expertise to the team. Paul has presented and been published on the use of normative data in analysis, respondent motives, trends in education and online communities, and respondent quality. Paul joined the team after serving as Senior Vice President for Advancement and Communications at Cairn University. Prior to founding research firm Charter Oak Research (now part of CACE), Paul was a Principal at Olson Research Group for 15 years as well as serving as the Associate Director of the Center for the Study of Federalism at Temple University responsible for qualitative research on political culture and U.S. Public Policy. Paul has served as an adjunct faculty member at several Philadelphia area universities. Paul is a graduate of Eastern (B.A.) and Villanova (M.A.) Universities and attended Temple University for further graduate study.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.