How to Use a Textbook for Deeper Learning: A lesson for our times

Steven LevyThe CACE Roundtable, The Teachers' LoungeLeave a Comment

I always used textbooks in my classes … but never how they were intended. They were valuable for me, as the teacher, to identify the important ideas in whatever subject I was teaching. We didn’t have state standards then, so I relied on the wisdom of the experts to break big topics (Ancient History, Simple Machines, Colonial Life, Force and Motion, Grammar) into teachable chunks. The table of contents provided a map for the specific topics we would explore.

Students in my classes used textbooks the way they might use a dictionary or encyclopedia. (We didn’t have the Internet then either.) The textbook was one of many references they might use to build background knowledge about a particular topic. We never read the textbook like a novel or followed it chapter by chapter. I didn’t need one for every student in the class–just a few in our classroom library.

Most textbooks are written with the intention of providing important facts and information about a certain subject. They often include questions at the end of each chapter to assess student learning. Even if the writing was dry and pre-digested (like a mother bird chewing up the worm to feed her chicks), there were often terrific illustrations, charts, and graphs. Here’s a model for how to use the textbook effectively to promote deeper learning (complex thinking, imagination, and lasting understanding).

What’s this?

1 virus

I am going to ask you to pause and do something I would probably not do myself. (I’d be anxious just to read on, as if somehow the author’s words were going to hand over some new insight.) But as in the classroom, so in the blog: the one who does the work does the learning. And the work here is not just reading but to take a few minutes to think about what this diagram is about. In a face-to-face classroom, I would ask students to write a paragraph to explain what is going on in the model. So, I’ll stop and let you ponder. . . .

If we were in class together, I’d invite you to share your “story” in triads. Then I would ask for people to nominate others in their group with particularly interesting stories to share their idea. Or they could share their own if they wanted. If you would like to see some 4th grade interpretations, check them out here. Sometimes (see the last 2 slides) I use images like this just to practice raising questions, the place where most science (and holy wonder) begins.

Now my students (and hopefully, you) have a theory as it were, a prediction, an inference, a “stake in the outcome.” You want to see if you were right. Maybe you will be more engaged when you see what this diagram is about. Check out the textbook story here.

After musing about the diagram themselves, students are more likely to be interested when they read about what is actually going on. They are also more likely to remember the information after having given their own names to the important parts of the diagram. To give something a name is to recognize that it represents an important concept or idea. That act creates a placeholder for the scientific vocabulary to replace the “character” you named in your story.

            “Oh, I called those three shapes ‘thingamagigs,’ but scientists call them. . . . “

            “I called those the ‘ribs,’ but biologists call them. . . .”

All I did was remove the labels from the diagram and invite students to grapple with the meaning before I showed them the answer. This grappling is one of the key elements of deeper learning (academically and spiritually!). Often we teachers, especially Americans, are prone to rescue our students when they confront challenges in learning. We tend to be too quick to step in and provide assistance. Self-efficacy and spiritual formation develop from experiences that demand perseverance and overcoming obstacles. We also learn from the stories and models of others whose growth is visible at the intersection of grace and sustained effort. (See this related chapter on “Constructive Struggling” by Cathy Seeley, former president of the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics.)

Grappling (see here for other words that represent nuances of its intent) invites students to try and make meaning, solve a problem, or engineer a design that they don’t know exactly how to do yet. They have to struggle individually; collaborate with peers; compare their solutions with other groups; debate the relevance, accuracy, or elegance of their work. The teacher observes their strategies, notes ones to highlight, asks questions, and presents new information. Perhaps most importantly, grappling fosters a growth mindset, where students develop an identity that says, “If I work hard, I can grow” rather than a fixed mindset that says, “I’m just not good at this.”

If you are going to use a textbook, look for photos, graphs, charts, etc. Remove the labels and let your students do some grappling before they receive the straight scoop. In both our cognitive and spiritual development, wrestling with meaning can deepen understanding and increase our receptivity to truth.


We acknowledge and suffer with all those whose lives have been devastated by the ravages of Covid-19. At the same time, many of us, by the grace of God, have discovered fresh dimensions of shalom as we create new rhythms in time and order in space.

Thank you to all who submitted responses to the RAFT I invited you to create in the April 14 blog. Please enjoy this Top Ten list created by Julie Mosley, College and Senior Advisor at Rocky Bayou Christian School in Florida.

Opportunities for Good During the Coronavirus Pandemic:

#10     Beach modesty has improved 100 percent.
#9       Your house can be a mess because no one is coming to visit you.
#8       Your teenagers want to run to the grocery store or pharmacy or fill the car with gas for you.
#7       Students are getting their work done in half the time without the constant class interruptions.
#6       Walking neighbors are talking more in a week, from a social distance than they have in a year.
#5       People are getting more sleep because they don’t have anything else to do at night.
#4       Long-distance families are zooming or skyping more than they did when they could get out.
#3       Since they are already sick of TV and internet, families are talking and playing games together.
#2       People are more thankful for the grave responsibilities of our leadership … at every level.
#1       More people are having time to reflect and reach out to God, Who brings good out of evil.

Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.